How to Pick the Best Type of Manicure for You (2024)

Hands and nails have become a major beauty focus more than ever lately (hello, repeated hand washing!). Enter the ever-important manicure: Not only is it a way to keep your nails healthy and polished, it's also a way to show your personality and creativity. Manicures let you try color or nail design trends without long-term —and potentially expensive — investments (like clothing) or irreversible options (like cutting your hair).

There are many factors that contribute to choosing your best manicure, including your mood, lifestyle, and budget, current trends, upkeep, how much time you have and how long you want the manicure to last. To help you find the ideal mani style for you, here is a guide to the different types of manicures from nail artist Julie Kandalec, owner of Julie K Nail Atelier in New York City.

Natural Nail Manicure

The au naturel manicure is great for the person that wants to just wear their own nails (it’s also called a classic manicure for a reason). This treatment includes cutting and filing your nails to your desired shape and length, cuticle grooming, a hand massage, and regular nail polish. Any other manicure you get is based on this regimen.

  • How long does it take? About one hour
  • How long does it last? Varies based on the individual, the technique, and the products used, but can last up to seven days
  • What is the price range? From $15 to $45+
  • Does it damage your nails? No
  • How do you remove this manicure? With non-acetone nail polish remover
  • Pros: A natural nails manicure is “easy maintenance and allows you to change your color quickly and easily," Kandalec says.
  • Cons: It can take time to dry (we’ve all bumped our nails and smudged our polish), and “it doesn’t last long for some if their hands are in water a lot," she adds.

Press-On Nails

If you want to DIY and get a perfect 10 mani with minimal effort (or dip your fingers into nail designs), press-on nails may be the way to go. "Press-ons are having a huge moment and the trend has staying power," Kandalec says. Press-on nails you can do at home are now higher quality, easier to use, and more believable, and you can even order custom nails tailored to your style and nails.

  • How long does it take? About 30 minutes to an hour, depending on your skill and comfort level
  • How long does it last? Approximately one to two weeks (they may pop off but you can reapply if needed)
  • What is the price range? About $6 and up
  • Do press-ons damage your nails? No, but if you are concerned, opt for the adhesive, knowing it may not be as strong and long-lasting as if you used glue.
  • How do you remove press-ons? Use acetone nail polish remover to loosen the glue. If you aren't a fan of acetone, take a cuticle-oil soaked cotton ball and apply it generously to each nail and especially the edges to ensure it gets under the nails to loosen the glue.
  • Pros: Press-on nails are generally easy to apply.
  • Cons: if you aren't careful or don't follow the instructions, you could potentially damage the top layer of your nails.

French Manicure

Traditionally, French manicures feature a natural-colored nail with a white tip, and can be done with regular nail polish, gel nail polish, or acrylic. They look clean and classic, but can feature fun twists. “A huge trend currently is a French twist manicure where the tip is different colors, like a rainbow or the shape is off-center for an easy nail art look," Kandalec says.

  • How long does it take? Tack an additional 10 to 30 minutes onto a basic manicure
  • How long does it last? In polish, about one week; in gel or acrylic, up to three weeks
  • What is the price range? Approximately $10 in a solid color; $15 and up in multiple colors
  • Does it damage your nails? No, this a manicure design.
  • How do you remove this manicure? It depends on the kind of manicure (gel, acrylic, etc.).
  • Pros: A glamorous, timeless look.
  • Cons: French manicures “can be difficult to do on yourself," she says, but you can use guide strips to help paint the tips.

American Manicure

The French manicure is ubiquitous, but did you know U.S.A. has its own version as well? "An American manicure is similar to a French manicure where the nail tips are lighter, but in a softer, more natural off-white color," Kandalec explains. It’s a flattering and classic way to wear the style of a French manicure and makes nails look healthy and clean.

  • How long does it take? Approximately 45 to 60 minutes for a natural manicure; two to three hours in acrylic or gel
  • How long does it last? About three to seven days in polish, up to three weeks in acrylic or gel
  • What is the price range? From around $40 to $130 and up
  • Does it damage your nails? No, this is a manicure design.
  • How do you remove this manicure? It depends on the kind of manicure (gel, acrylic, etc.).
  • Pros: An American mani is easier to DIY. "It's possible to do this yourself at home because the white tip is softer and doesn’t have to be perfect," she says.
  • Cons: Might be too natural looking for some.

Acrylic Manicure

Trying to get those striking stiletto and coffin-shaped nails? Opt for acrylic, which is a liquid plus powder nail enhancement that's very strong. There’s a chemistry (literally!) to acrylics: “The powder is a polymer and the liquid is a monomer and when they are mixed together in the proper ratio, they harden on their own," Kandalec explains, no UV light needed for curing. “Acrylic gets a bad reputation because so frequently they are done very thick, but acrylic can be applied very thinly and in a natural way if it is filed flush at the cuticle.”

  • How long does it take? About two hours
  • How long does it last? Approximately two to three weeks
  • What is the price range? Around $120+ for a new set
  • Do acrylic nails damage natural nails? No, as long as you don't leave your acrylics on for too long and remove them correctly.
  • How do you remove acrylic nails? If you are at home, soak your nails in acetone nail polish remover for five minutes, then remove the nail polish. Repeat this process until the polish is off. A salon will do similar with 100% acetone.
  • Pros: Acrylics are hard and durable.
  • Cons: The odor of acrylic is very strong during application and not appealing for some."Sometimes the enhancement is so strong that if you do break a nail, it can cause a lot of pain and potential damage to the natural nail plate underneath," she says. “But it’s not a reason to avoid it — just be sure to visit a salon with an excellent reputation for best results."

Gel Manicure

For a durable manicure, consider hard gel. “You can sculpt nails with hard gel, and a professional has to remove it by filing, as it’s acetone-resistant," Kandalec says. These nails can look very natural while being lightweight and flexible. A hard gel manicure is “much more flexible than acrylic and better for people prone to nail lifting because it flexes with the nail shape nicely," she explains

  • How long does it take? About two hours
  • How long does it last? Approximately three weeks
  • What is the price range? From about $30 to $120+
  • Does gel damage natural nails? No, as long as you don't leave the gel on for too long and you remove the polish correctly.
  • How do you remove a gel manicure? Take a cotton ball soaked in acetone nail polish and apply to your finger nails and wrap each nail with foil for about 15 minutes. The polish should easily remove, if not, soak again.
  • Pros: “Hard gel is self-leveling and can leave a very high gloss shine on the nail without even needing to add color," Kandalec notes.
  • Cons: It does need to be removed by a professional.

Shellac Manicure

Want to give your gel manicure an upgrade? Opt for a Shellac manicure. A Shellac manicure is essentially a gel manicure; however, Shellac is the name of the brand of gel polish created by Creative Nail Design (CND). The brand has bragging rights of being the original gel polish and over 160 colors to choose from.

  • How long does it take? About two hours
  • How long does it last? Approximately three weeks
  • What is the price range? From about $30 to $120+
  • Does shellac damage your nails? No, as long as you don't leave it on for too long and or remove it incorrectly.
  • How do you remove a shellac manicure? First, buff the shine off the nail polish with a nail file. Then take a cotton ball soaked in acetone nail polish and apply to your finger nails and wrap each nail with foil for about 15 minutes. The polish should easily remove. If not, soak again.
  • Pros: Two times faster removal in comparison to competitors.
  • Cons: It does need to be removed by a professional.

Dip Powder Manicure

Dip powder nails are a powder and glue combination that bonds to your nails for a long-lasting manicure. “This technique was very popular many years ago and just began to resurface in the nail industry recently," Kandalec shares. (Dip powder nails are also known as SNS nails, though SNS is a brand of dip powder.)

  • How long does it take? About two hours
  • How long does it last? Approximately four weeks
  • What is the price range? Similar to a gel manicure, around $30 to $5
  • Does dip powder damage your nails? No, as long as you don't leave the gel on for too long, remove the polish correctly, and give your natural nails a break every couple of months.
  • How do you remove a dip powder manicure? First buff the shine off the nail polish with a nail file. Then take a cotton ball soaked in acetone nail polish and apply to your finger nails and wrap each nail with foil for about 15 minutes. The polish should easily remove, if not, soak again.
  • Pros: Long-lasting, durable results.
  • Cons: It's important to choose a reputable salon for this treatment. Ensure your nail tech allocates a portion of the dip powder from the pot for your manicure, as dipping your nail into the main pot is unhygienic and can spread germs.

Plexigel Manicure

A new type of salon manicure from nail brand CND, Plexigel consists of two different main products— a nail shaper and builder are tailored to your nail needs. “Shaper is for repairs, cracks, and plumping the natural nail, while Builder lets you build out long nails or other shapes," Kandalec explains. The tough coating naturally protects your nails and is more lightweight in comparison to other nail enhancements, and Plexigel rivals regular gel in terms of how long it lasts.

  • How long does it take? For a new set, about two hours
  • How long does it last? Up to three weeks
  • What is the price range? Starting at $130 for a new set, sculpted on forms
  • Does plexigel damage your nails? No, as long as you remove correctly.
  • How do you remove a plexigel manicure? You don't. Head to a nail tech trained in the CND plexigel process to have this removed. You can find a technician via their website.
  • Pros: Plexigel easily adds length and shape to your natural nails and is lightweight. The nails can also be rebalanced every three weeks without the need for removal, which saves time.
  • Cons: Only a CND-trained professional can apply and remove it.

How to Pick the Best Type of Manicure for You (10)

Danielle James

Digital Beauty Director

Danielle James is the Digital Beauty Director of ELLE.com. Previously, she was the Fashion and Beauty Director of HelloBeautiful.com and MadameNoire.com. She’s written for The Cut, InStyle, Allure, The Business of Fashion, Nylon, Essence, Good Housekeeping, and more. She enjoys sailing, thrifting, Japanese whiskey, Naomi Campbell’s runway walk, and Rihanna in the comment section.

How to Pick the Best Type of Manicure for You (2024)

FAQs

How to Pick the Best Type of Manicure for You? ›

In summary, when choosing between gel and acrylic nails, it's important to consider your lifestyle, natural nail health, budget, desired look and level of maintenance. Both types of nails have their pros and cons and the best option depends on the individual's needs, preferences, and budget.

How do I know what kind of nails to get? ›

In summary, when choosing between gel and acrylic nails, it's important to consider your lifestyle, natural nail health, budget, desired look and level of maintenance. Both types of nails have their pros and cons and the best option depends on the individual's needs, preferences, and budget.

What manicure is least damaging to nails? ›

Overall, Dip Powder Manicures are a great way to get a healthy manicure that will protect and strengthen your nails without causing any damage. Just like any nail treatment, you do have to make sure you properly remove it to keep your nails safe and healthy – Don't pick at your manicure!

Is gel or dip better for your nails? ›

Gel Nail Polish is formulated to restrict the growth of microbes, so you can rest easy knowing there's no cause for concern. Whilst the durability of a dip manicure may seem desirable, it can actually come as a detriment to your nail health.

What different types of manicures do you know about? ›

Top 12 Different Types Of Manicures
  • French manicure. ...
  • Hot oil manicure. ...
  • Paraffin wax treatment. ...
  • Dip powder manicure. ...
  • Classic Manicure. ...
  • Gel Manicure. ...
  • Acrylic Manicure. ...
  • Shellac Manicure.

How do I choose my nail type? ›

when choosing a nail shape, there are a few things to keep in mind: your natural nail width, your nail length and your style. if you're unsure where to start, choose a shape that most closely resembles the shape of your cuticles, ie: if you have straight cuticles, choose a square shape.

How do I choose a manicure? ›

Which Type of Manicure is Best for Your Nails?
  1. If you have weak or brittle nails, consider a regular or shellac manicure as they are less damaging.
  2. If longevity is a priority, opt for a gel or dip powder manicure.
  3. If you want to add length or dramatically change your nail shape, acrylics could be your best bet.
Sep 13, 2023

What is the healthiest manicure at a salon? ›

Unlike traditional techniques like acrylic or gel, dip powder nails do not require any UV light exposure. This eliminates the potential harm caused by UV lights, making dip powder a healthier choice. Moreover, dip powder nails are known to be highly resistant to chipping and peeling, ensuring longer-lasting manicures.

What is the healthiest way to get your nails done? ›

Artificial nails: Dermatologists' tips for reducing nail damage
  • Choose soak-off gel nails instead of acrylic nails. ...
  • Go to a salon that uses an LED curing light rather than a UV curing light. ...
  • Ask your nail technician to skip the cuticle trimming. ...
  • Reserve artificial nails for special occasions.

What is the best manicure to keep nails from breaking? ›

Frequent application and reapplication of press-ons may cause peeling, chipping and thinning of the nail bed. For longer-lasting long nails, head to the salon for gel extensions or acrylics. Both run between $90 and $120 and can be used with regular, gel or dip-powder polish.

What is a Russian manicure? ›

The Russian nail method is a dry process of filing, cutting, and removing the cuticle with electric drill bits entirely for a clean look and feel. The Russian manicure can prevent the dry cracking of cuticles or hangnails, thus extending the longevity of the manicure.

What type of manicure lasts the longest? ›

For the longest-lasting manicure, choose a gel or acrylic style. Gel nail polish is less likely to chip, and acrylic is even stronger than gel.

Why do my nails hurt after dip powder? ›

If your dip powder manicure is not done correctly, it can also cause your nails to feel weird. If the layers of powder and liquids are applied too thickly or unevenly, it can create an imbalance in pressure on your nail bed, leading to discomfort or numbness.

What is the least damaging manicure? ›

Acrylics. Acrylic manicures are a classic for good reason: they offer extra length, and durability, thanks to being adhered with gel glue. Plus, if you remove them properly (i.e. by soaking and with a professional) they won't cause damage to your natural nail.

What is the new nail technique better than gel? ›

Polygel nails are stronger than gel nails and more flexible than acrylic nails, which makes them less likely to chip or break. “If someone is hard on their hands, it bounces back more easily instead of cracking,” says Kandalec.

What is the most popular manicure shape? ›

Almond. As the name suggests, an almond-shaped nail has a tip shaped like the narrow side of the popular nut. Slightly longer like an oval nail shape, it starts to get slimmer the closer you are to the tip without it being too pointy. “This is a flattering shape on anyone and probably the most popular,” says Falcone.

How do I know what nail shape is best for me? ›

If you have short palms and short fingers, it's best to opt for rounded oval and almond shapes. For longer palms and fingers, consider dramatic stiletto or coffin (or ballerina) shaped styles. Almond shaped nails tend to suit everyone.

What are the best types of nails to get? ›

For the longest-lasting manicure, choose a gel or acrylic style. Gel nail polish is less likely to chip, and acrylic is even stronger than gel.

Is gel or acrylic better for your nails? ›

However, if you crave a more natural look and prioritize nail health, then a gel manicure might be better. Gel polish offers a high-shine finish and may be less damaging, but it can sometimes chip more easily than acrylics. Consider your lifestyle and nail goals to make the best pick. Ultimately, you can try them both.

Which artificial nails are least damaging? ›

Choose soak-off gel nails instead of acrylic nails.

While gel nails can cause nail brittleness, peeling, and cracking, they're more flexible than acrylic nails. This means your own nails are less likely to crack. You'll want to ask for gel nails that soak off rather than ones that must be filed off.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Patricia Veum II

Last Updated:

Views: 5611

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (64 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Patricia Veum II

Birthday: 1994-12-16

Address: 2064 Little Summit, Goldieton, MS 97651-0862

Phone: +6873952696715

Job: Principal Officer

Hobby: Rafting, Cabaret, Candle making, Jigsaw puzzles, Inline skating, Magic, Graffiti

Introduction: My name is Patricia Veum II, I am a vast, combative, smiling, famous, inexpensive, zealous, sparkling person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.